New Horror Movie Revival Reveals Our Deepest Fears

Horror movies are huge right now — and not just because it is the month of Halloween. All year long, horror films have been gaining new levels of critical respect and box office success.

I think I know why.

Every culture uses stories to process truths we can’t face more straightforwardly: Fictional dramas help us think through the tension we face in relationships, science fiction prepares us for the changing world, and horror movies allow us to acknowledge the things we fear but have no natural way to talk about — supernatural forces and our own darkest tendencies.

I watched the biggest horror movies of 2026 and recent years to see what the newest ones are saying. I watched them fast forward in some cases (I scare very easily) and skipped unwatchable scenes altogether (always check content reviews such as IMDB Parents’ Guide).

Here are my thoughts about why the horror genre is so popular in the culture right now, in four different categories that our horror movies speak to.

First, a surprising number of new horror movies are about psychological trauma.

Horror has always helped explored the dark psychological twists and turns the human mind can take, from Doctor Jekyll and Mr. Hyde to The Shining. Our big new horror movies update the approach to our newest psychological categories.

Backrooms (2026) starring Chiwetel Ejiofor (above) is a horror movie that grew out of an internet trend exploring an “evil Narnia” world of fluorescent-lighted corporate hallways and rooms. In the movie, the backrooms are shaped by visitors’ darkest experiences and the psychological loops they can’t escape. It’s not fun to watch but I couldn’t stop thinking about it. It clearly wants to address trauma, but there is so much more implicated here: The horror of the backrooms mirrors our weariness with liminal “nonplaces” that modernity multiplies everywhere, as well as our addiction to scrolling through endless online experiences without getting anywhere.

Hokum (2026) starring Adam Scott is an old-school horror movie about a man visiting the Irish hotel his parents honeymooned in. He is haunted by a mistake he made growing up, and the hotel he is in is haunted too.

Smile (2022) is another movie about a demon who enters through psychological trauma. It causes victims to smile until it destroys them — which is what real trauma does, too, when we try to ignore it.

Second, a number of horror movies examine family brokenness.

Of course, these movies about trauma are often about family-related trauma. Others look directly at the family.

Other Mommy (2026) starring Jessica Chastain (above) has a quietly terrifying trailer that’s hard to forget. It shows an eerily smiling mother asking to live inside her daughter the way her daughter once lived inside her. It is based on John Malerman’s book Incidents Around the House, and like other movies on this list, it is also about a demonic being looking for an “in”. In this one, it is the corrosive power of family secrets that provides an opening.

Boogeyman (2023) is about a family mourning a mom’s death, who at first don’t believe the daughter who says there is a monster in her room. But there is — a monster who feeds off the family’s pain. These movies recognize the resiliency families have, until failures in love undermine them and they collapse into pain.

Hereditary (2018) starring Toni Collette is different from the others. I watched it because it has been hailed as the new standard for horror. It does the thing that I hate in horror movies: It attacks hope by taking places of safety (faith, family, and friendships) and twisting them into tools of evil.

Third are movies that acknowledge that sex has far more importance than our culture gives it.

In the 1980s, slasher movies borrowed some of their terrifying power by showing teens who break taboos becoming the first to be killed. It came at a time when the culture still had qualms about our newly loosened sexual morals. Our offended consciences sharpened the horror. In the 21st century, consciences are more numbed, so horror movies raise new issues around sex.

Obsession (2026) starring Inde Navarrette in a harrowing performance is a movie about a guy (Michael Johnston, shown above) who is so afraid to tell his crush, Nikki, that he likes her, he wins her over with a “One Wish Willow” talisman from a novelty shop instead. She becomes devoted to him — but he is still occasionally able to see the pained reluctance of the real Nikki, who is still there inside the body of the girl who is trapped by his wish. The real villain here is the weak, self-centered man who prefers a woman with no agency. I have no idea if the filmmakers meant to, but the film’s story absolutely implicates our male-centered culture where sex is expected of women and where pornography is the most lucrative entertainment media of our time — and where the pornographic mindset has led naturally to an explosion in human trafficking.

It Follows (2014) deserves mention because it caused a huge sensation more than 10 years ago. In it, a killer demon or “entity” stalks people after they have sexual encounters. I don’t think it was the fear of STDs that made it so talked-about — I think the movie acknowledged a truth we all know but rarely voice. The emotional connections forged by casual sexual encounters are never causal. They haunt us, unstoppably — like the creatures in the film.

Fourth are a few movies that show the culture trying to process religious questions.

The biggest horror movies have always asked religious questions, from Dracula to The Exorcist. As our world became more and more secularized, and banished talk of the supernatural, we kept to ourselves our suspicions that there is more in the universe than mere matter — and we lost our certainty that the supernatural world was on balance good instead of evil. Our big new horror movies are asking the same questions: What is behind the veil of the hidden world? Is it more likely to save us, or destroy us?

Heretic (2024) is a Hugh Grant movie about two Mormon missionaries who visit the house of an anti-religious extremist who seems charming and harmless but is anything but. To its credit, the movie treats the missionaries with respect and compassion and their tormentor with contempt. Unfortunately, it also allows the villain spouts the long-discredited “fact” that many religious myths tell stories that match Christ’s closely in specific details. They absolutely do not. Before the movie gets overly gory, and even while it does, Grant’s quiet good humor and good manners make him a truly frightening villain — and a telling standard-bearer for secularist extremism.

Life of Chuck (2024) starring Tom Hiddleston is not a horror film, though it has horror elements including mysterious natural disasters, strange secret deaths, and a house’s locked copula room that you must not enter. The movie is not perfect, but its central metaphor does a beautiful job of illustrating the grandeur of humanity and the infinite dignity of the human person.

A Quiet Place (2018 — part 3 coming in 2027) from John Krasinski is the most watchable horror movie on the list, content-wise — though the nail on the staircase still haunts me. A Bishop Robert Barron review swears it’s religious. See if you agree with him.

Images: Alamy
A version of this appeared at Aleteia.

By

Dear Reader,

Would you like to better understand the spiritual depth and daily insights of Jesus' parables?

We'd like to offer you our FREE video series, Christ the Storyteller. Each episode of this series will help you experience the profound truths Jesus conveys in each parable.

In 10 short lectures, Dr. Andrew Swafford, Professor of Theology, dwells on a different parable—revealing their theological meaning, spiritual insight, and practical guidance for everyday Catholic living.

Start your FREE video series today and explore the practical wisdom of Jesus’ Parables!

Receive My Free Video Series »