Joseph Ratzinger, Theologian of Reason and Revelation
Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger’s greatest contributions are in fundamental theology, Spanish theologian Father José Granados told Theology faculty.
At September’s end, as the summer’s heat overstayed its welcome, the theology faculty enjoyed a lunchtime address by Father José Granados, former vice president of the Pontifical John Paul II Institute for Studies on Marriage and Family and current Superior General of the Disciples of the Hearts of Jesus and Mary. Over the past six years, Benedictine College has partnered with the Disciples on the College’s Center for Family Life, which just installed Father Stefan Zarnay, DCJM, as its director in August. An accomplished and respected theologian in his own right, Father Granados encouraged us to consider the legacy of Joseph Ratzinger and to take up his project our own as we approach the 100th anniversary of his birth in April.
Ratzinger was trained during an era of what might be called “encyclopedic theologians,” theologians who wrote voluminously and freely on a great many subjects. Simply search the names of Hans Urs von Balthasar, Henri de Lubac, Yves Congar, and Karl Barth. Whereas today a prolific theologian might publish ten books during his or her career, it was not uncommon for these theologians to have published well over 50 before their time came.
Whereas today’s theologians frequently feel restricted by their expertise, almost disqualified from discussing topics that fall even slightly outside their topic of study, theologians of this era felt no shame in discoursing about subjects well wide of their own field of study and integrating different disciplines. Consider Balthasar whose doctorate was primarily in literature not theology. The Swiss Jesuit quite confidently moved from historical-criticism of the Bible, to interpretations of eastern patristic theologians, to constructive speculations on the atonement and eschatology, to pioneering an aesthetical interpretation of Christian metaphysics and doctrine.
Ratzinger was similarly encyclopedic. He ingeniously wrote on subjects as diverse as theological epistemology, the spiritual roots and projects of western civilization, the liturgy, scriptural hermeneutics, political philosophy, interfaith dialogue, and the historical Jesus. If you were to ask what his major work was, you would likely get several answers. The work that would come most immediately to most people’s minds is his Introduction to Christianity. A close second might be his Jesus of Nazareth trilogy published during his pontificate. It sold over 7 million copies worldwide. At this point not a few readers would be mumbling about The Spirit of the Liturgy, which opened several avenues of liturgical scholarship and spawned a generation of priests engaged in liturgical rediscovery.
Father Granados proposed Fundamental Theology as the discipline most central to Ratzinger’s thought and to which he contributed most substantially. Fundamental Theology is the branch of theology that establishes the epistemological possibility of theology, identifying the sources for knowledge of God, outlining their credibility as well as their limitations, and setting out a scientific methodology for engaging them. Topics treated in Fundamental Theology include the knowledge of God given through nature and the knowledge of God given through history, the inspiration and interpretation of Scripture, the nature and content of Tradition, the relationship between faith and reason, the development of doctrine, and the role of the Magisterium.
Fr. Granados observed that what distinguished Ratzinger from many of his peers is that while they were increasingly engaged with critical social theory, Ratzinger retained a traditional commitment to philosophy as theology’s handmaid. Thus, Ratzinger persisted in believing theology is preoccupied with the question of truth and continued to insist upon the appropriately contemplative dimensions of human reason. This allowed him to see that theology is necessarily speculative, that is, it rightly considers the reality of God as such and is not just a religious gloss on human ethical consciousness or political advocacy.
According to Father Granados, Ratzinger was still able to incorporate the rightful place of human subjectivity and transformative action into a more classical prioritization of the reality and activity of God by developing an understanding of revelation as the Word. As God’s Word, revelation is not fundamentally human self-expression but divine self-disclosure. Yet, as communication, God’s Word requires hearers. Human subjectivity is included in the act of revelation, yet it takes the form of response. Importantly, this human response is not autonomous. It is superintended by divine grace. For Ratzinger, the Word is heard in the Church, principally in the liturgy, and faith is tutored by the divinely authorized Magisterium.
Although an obscure and oft-forgotten dimension of theological reflection, Fundamental Theology is indeed fundamental. Beyond articulating the bases and sources for knowledge of God, Fundamental Theology establishes what might be called the culture of theology. It identifies theology’s purpose, shared authorities or sources for knowledge, a common methodology, and what it looks like to faithfully receive divine revelation. Without a shared understanding of topics such as the relationship between faith and reason, the way to distinguish between a doctrinal development and a doctrinal corruption, the principles of biblical interpretation, and the relationship among Scripture, Tradition, and Magisterium, theology degenerates into ideology and tribal advocacy. In short, without a robust and public Fundamental Theology, Catholic doctrine ceases to be catholic or universal. Here Fr. Granados’ encouragement to not only to turn to Ratzinger as a resource for a renewal of Fundamental Theology but to make this discipline foundational to our own work as theological educators ought to be taken seriously.
Image: Levan Ramishvili Flickr, Ratzinger.
Dear Reader,
Would you like to better understand the spiritual depth and daily insights of Jesus' parables?
We'd like to offer you our FREE video series, Christ the Storyteller. Each episode of this series will help you experience the profound truths Jesus conveys in each parable.
In 10 short lectures, Dr. Andrew Swafford, Professor of Theology, dwells on a different parable—revealing their theological meaning, spiritual insight, and practical guidance for everyday Catholic living.
Start your FREE video series today and explore the practical wisdom of Jesus’ Parables!
Receive My Free Video Series »

